Location: Buffalo, NY
I was involved in a very minor hit and run where I only had a small paint marks on the car. I filed a report with the police and they found him at his home and they ticketed him. I didn't feel it was necessary to go to insurance to file a claim, since the damage was so minor and the police already ticketed him. I got a call from my insurance company asking about the accident about a month later and I explained what happened and sent in the police report and the claim was closed out. A few days later I got a letter in the mail from GEICO which was his insurance saying they were trying to reach me about the accident but couldn't get ahold me. I contacted them and they said he was claiming I was at fault for the accident so I gave a statement and submitted the police report to GEICO.
I received a call last week from GEICO informing me I was deemed 100% at fault for the accident and the person on the phone could give me no additional information.
I have no point of contact for anything going on here.
What do I do from here? GEICO isn't my insurance so surely they can't force me to pay for his damages.